Does Panera Still Have the French Toast Bagel?

Panera Bread is well known for its fresh bakery items, delicious sandwiches, and comforting soups. Among its popular menu offerings, bagels have been a favorite choice for many customers. One particular standout was the French Toast Bagel, which combined the warm, sweet flavors of cinnamon and vanilla with the chewy texture of a bagel. However, many fans have noticed that it has been missing from the menu in recent years, leading to the big question: Does Panera still have the French Toast Bagel?

In this article, we’ll explore the history of the French Toast Bagel, why it was discontinued, possible alternatives, and whether it might return in the future.

The Popularity of Panera’s French Toast Bagel

Panera’s French Toast Bagel was a fan-favorite because of its unique combination of flavors. It was lightly sweetened, had hints of cinnamon, and was often paired with cream cheese or butter for an extra indulgent treat. Many customers loved having it as a breakfast option or a mid-day snack with a cup of coffee.

Why Was It So Popular?

1. Delicious Flavor – The mix of cinnamon, vanilla, and sugar made it taste like classic French toast.
2. Soft and Chewy Texture – Unlike regular bagels, it had a slightly softer and more dessert-like texture.
3. Versatility – It was perfect with both sweet and savory spreads, making it a go-to option for many customers.

However, despite its popularity, Panera Bread decided to remove it from its menu, leaving many fans disappointed.

Panera’s Menu Changes Over Time

Like many restaurant chains, Panera frequently updates its menu to introduce new items and remove underperforming ones. Over the years, Panera has made several menu adjustments, including the discontinuation of certain bagel flavors, soups, and sandwiches.

Why Does Panera Discontinue Menu Items?

• Supply Chain Challenges – Some ingredients become expensive or difficult to source.
• Low Sales Performance – If an item doesn’t sell well compared to others, it may be removed.
• Menu Simplification – Panera periodically streamlines its menu to improve efficiency in their kitchens.

Unfortunately, the French Toast Bagel was one of the casualties of these menu changes.

Is the French Toast Bagel Still Available?

As of 2025, Panera does not have the French Toast Bagel on its menu. The item was officially discontinued in 2020 during a menu revamp. Many customers have since searched for it at different Panera locations, but it has not returned to the lineup.

Can You Still Find It in Some Locations?

Some Panera locations may have seasonal or limited-time offerings, but currently, the French Toast Bagel is not listed on the official menu. The best way to check is to visit Panera’s website or ask your local Panera Bread if they offer any special bagels.

Why Did Panera Discontinue the French Toast Bagel?

Panera has not provided a specific reason for removing the French Toast Bagel, but there are a few likely explanations:

1. Menu Reduction Strategy – During 2020, Panera simplified its menu, removing several items.
2. Low Sales Performance – Although beloved by many, it may not have been a top seller nationwide.
3. Ingredient Availability – If sourcing ingredients became difficult, Panera may have chosen to discontinue it.

Whatever the reason, its removal left many customers disappointed and hoping for its return.

Customer Reactions and Demand for Its Return

Since Panera Bread removed the French Toast Bagel from its menu, many loyal customers have voiced their disappointment. Social media platforms like Twitter, Facebook, and Reddit have been flooded with posts from fans reminiscing about the sweet, cinnamon-flavored bagel and calling for its return.

How Have Customers Reacted?

1. Social Media Outcry – Many customers have shared their disappointment online, tagging Panera Bread and requesting the bagel’s return.
2. Online Petitions – Some fans have gone as far as creating petitions urging Panera to bring it back, gathering thousands of signatures.
3. Customer Feedback – Numerous complaints and requests have been submitted through Panera’s customer service channels, hoping to influence the company’s decision.

Despite this demand, Panera has not officially announced any plans to reintroduce the French Toast Bagel to its menu.

Are There Any Alternatives to the French Toast Bagel at Panera?

Even though the French Toast Bagel is no longer available, Panera still offers a variety of other bagels that could serve as alternatives. If you’re craving something similar, here are a few options to try:

1. Cinnamon Crunch Bagel

• Features a sweet cinnamon-sugar topping with a crunchy texture.
• Similar warm cinnamon flavors to the French Toast Bagel, though slightly sweeter.
• Pairs well with Panera’s honey walnut cream cheese for an extra touch of sweetness.

2. Cinnamon Swirl Bagel

• Has a swirl of cinnamon throughout the dough, giving it a rich flavor.
• A great substitute if you enjoy the cinnamon aspect of the French Toast Bagel.
• Can be toasted and topped with butter or cream cheese for a more indulgent treat.

3. Blueberry Bagel

• While it lacks the cinnamon, the slight sweetness makes it another good alternative.
• A fruity option for those who prefer a lighter, sweeter bagel.

While these options might not be an exact match, they can still provide a satisfying alternative for those missing the French Toast Bagel.

Can You Make a Copycat Version at Home?

For fans who are determined to enjoy the flavors of the French Toast Bagel, making a homemade version is a great option! With a few simple ingredients, you can recreate the taste of Panera’s beloved bagel.

Homemade French Toast Bagel Recipe

Ingredients:

• 3 ½ cups bread flour
• 1 packet instant yeast
• 1 tablespoon cinnamon
• 1 teaspoon salt
• 1 tablespoon sugar
• 1 cup warm water
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 2 tablespoons maple syrup
• 1 egg (for egg wash)

Instructions:

1. Prepare the Dough – In a bowl, mix the flour, yeast, cinnamon, salt, and sugar. Slowly add warm water, vanilla extract, and maple syrup while stirring.
2. Knead the Dough – Knead for about 10 minutes until the dough becomes smooth and elastic.
3. Let It Rise – Cover and let the dough rise for 1-2 hours, or until doubled in size.
4. Shape the Bagels – Divide the dough into equal portions and form bagel shapes.
5. Boil the Bagels – Drop each bagel into boiling water for 30-45 seconds per side to create the signature chewy texture.
6. Bake – Brush the bagels with an egg wash and bake at 375°F (190°C) for 20-25 minutes or until golden brown.

For an authentic Panera-like flavor, sprinkle a cinnamon-sugar mixture on top before baking. Enjoy with cream cheese, honey, or butter for a perfect homemade alternative!

Will Panera Bring Back the French Toast Bagel?

As of now, Panera Bread has not made any announcements regarding the return of the French Toast Bagel. However, menu items do return from time to time based on customer demand.

Is There Hope for Its Return?

• Panera has brought back other discontinued bagels, such as the Sesame and Blueberry Bagels after customer feedback.
• If enough customers request it, Panera might consider reintroducing the French Toast Bagel as a seasonal or limited-time item.
• Following Panera on social media or signing up for email updates can help fans stay informed about menu changes and possible returns.

For now, fans will have to wait and see if Panera listens to their requests!

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

1. When did Panera discontinue the French Toast Bagel?

Panera removed the French Toast Bagel in 2020 as part of a menu simplification strategy.

2. Can I still find the French Toast Bagel at any Panera locations?

Currently, no locations have it listed on their official menu. However, some locations may offer seasonal bagels similar to it.

3. What is the closest alternative to the French Toast Bagel?

The Cinnamon Crunch Bagel is the closest in terms of sweetness and cinnamon flavor.

4. Does Panera ever bring back discontinued menu items?

Yes! Panera has brought back items based on customer demand, so there’s always a chance for its return.

5. How can I request Panera to bring back the French Toast Bagel?

You can submit a request through Panera’s customer feedback form on their website or contact them on social media.

Conclusion

While the French Toast Bagel was once a beloved staple at Panera Bread, it is no longer available as of 2025. Despite customer demand, Panera has not yet announced any plans to bring it back. However, fans can still enjoy similar options like the Cinnamon Crunch Bagel or even make their own homemade version.

If you’re hoping for a comeback, staying active on social media, signing up for Panera Rewards, and voicing your support may increase the chances of its return. Until then, the search for the perfect French Toast Bagel alternative continues!